pixel

Birthright Citizenship and Children Born Through ART: Constitutional Questions, Supreme Court Action, and Nationwide Injunctions

Children born through assisted reproductive technology (ART), including surrogacy and donor conception, are increasingly at the center of complex legal battles involving citizenship, parentage, and constitutional rights. In recent years, challenges to Trump-era restrictions on birthright citizenship have brought this intersection to federal courts, where families formed via ART fought for the recognition of their children’s U.S. citizenship.

Notably, the U.S. Supreme Court has yet to issue a direct ruling on ART-related birthright citizenship. But its decision to decline certiorari in several cases has allowed significant lower court rulings to stand. Meanwhile, the Court has also expressed skepticism about nationwide injunctions, a procedural mechanism that was key to blocking restrictive federal policies. The legal landscape reveals a striking tension between procedural conservatism and substantive equal protection.

The Legal Challenge: Genetics v. Legal Parenthood

Under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), a child born abroad may acquire U.S. citizenship at birth if one parent is a U.S. citizen and meets certain residency requirements. For decades, the U.S. Department of State interpreted this to require a biological relationship between the U.S. citizen parent and the child.

This policy posed unique burdens on same-sex couples, intended parents using surrogates, and families utilizing donor gametes. If the U.S. citizen parent lacked a genetic tie, despite being a legal parent under state or foreign law, their child was denied automatic citizenship.

Landmark Federal Court Decisions

Several federal lawsuits challenged this interpretation on constitutional and statutory grounds. Among the most significant:

Mize-Gregg v. Pompeo, 541 F. Supp. 3d 124 (D.D.C. 2021)

Two U.S. citizen fathers challenged the State Department’s refusal to recognize their child, born abroad via surrogacy and lacking a genetic tie to one parent, as a U.S. citizen. The court held that the agency’s reliance on biology was inconsistent with the INA and discriminatory under equal protection principles.

Kiviti v. Pompeo, 2020 WL 3268221 (D. Md. June 17, 2020)

A similar case involving a same-sex couple found the State Department’s policy violated the Administrative Procedure Act and the Fifth Amendment.

D.M.T. v. Secretary of State, 426 F. Supp. 3d 130 (D.D.C. 2019)

Again, the court struck down the policy, emphasizing that legal parentage, not genetics, should control citizenship determinations for children born through ART.

These cases collectively marked a significant shift in how federal law treats ART-born children, affirming the legitimacy of non-genetic parentage and offering families stronger constitutional protection.

The Supreme Court’s Passive Endorsement

Despite the government’s efforts to overturn these decisions, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear appeals in these cases. Though the Court issued no opinions, its refusal to grant certiorari functionally let the rulings stand.

This strategic silence had real impact:

Children born abroad to legally recognized U.S. parents, regardless of genetics, were granted birthright citizenship.

Intended parents no longer had to fear exclusion simply because they used ART.

Nationwide Injunctions: A Quiet Threat?

At the same time, the Supreme Court has grown increasingly skeptical of nationwide injunctions, which many lower courts used to block federal policies like the genetic-parent requirement.

In Department of Homeland Security v. New York, 140 S. Ct. 599 (2020), the Court stayed a nationwide injunction against the public charge rule. Justice Gorsuch’s concurring opinion criticized the “trend” of issuing such broad relief, arguing it disrupted the balance of judicial power.

Although these critiques did not target ART cases specifically, any curtailment of nationwide injunctions could make it harder for vulnerable families to challenge federal overreach in the future.

 Legal Takeaways

  1. Legal Parentage Prevails
    The trend in federal courts supports the idea that citizenship should flow from lawful parental status, not strictly from DNA.
  2. Supreme Court Passivity Matters
    The Court’s refusal to intervene has allowed ART-supportive rulings to become de facto law in several jurisdictions.
  3. Procedural Tools Are at Risk
    If nationwide injunctions are limited, reproductive justice cases may become harder to litigate, especially where plaintiffs lack standing in multiple jurisdictions.
  4. State Law Still Matters
    In many ART cases, federal recognition of parentage begins with state-level parentage orders or judgments. Practitioners must ensure those orders are robust and clearly drafted.

The rights of children born through ART continue to evolve at the intersection of constitutional law, immigration policy, and family law. While the U.S. Supreme Court has not spoken explicitly on the issue, its silence has, for now, affirmed lower courts’ embrace of a more inclusive, modern understanding of family and citizenship.

As legal advocates, we must continue to safeguard access to parentage, citizenship, and recognition for all families, regardless of genetics, geography, or the method by which a child comes into the world.

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

If you have questions about birthright citizenship, legal parentage, or protecting your family’s rights through assisted reproductive technology, we’re here to help. We provide guidance tailored to your family’s unique circumstances so you can move forward with clarity and confidence. Contact us today to schedule a consultation.